The Royal NSW Canine Council PO Box 632 St Marys NSW 2760
Australia
P & D Hopwood (Viewpoint, Canine
Journal February 1996) sounded a warning to others after their spaniel choked
on a raw chicken wing. Natural grief will always lead to justifiable soul
searching in an urgent attempt to avoid similar disasters. After offering
my sympathies may I be permitted to counsel caution and the need for a broad
view.
Many years ago when I was vet in attendance at a safari park one of the lions
died suddenly. Post mortem examination revealed cause of death to be bowel
perforation by a sharp sawn section of ox vertebra. Another tigress was sick
for a number of days . At exploratory laparotomy raw bones were found impacting
the bowel. Whilst dramatic outcomes can occur when wild animals consume natural
food we nonetheless concluded that it was the unnatural aspects of the feeding,
sawing the bone , which created the problems. At the time we were most perturbed
but were not tempted to commence the feeding of artificial foods to large
carnivores.
Curiously I adopted the opposite point of view with regard to the dietary
requirements of small domestic carnivores. I advised my clients that the
safe convenient way to feed their pets was out of the can. I was comfortable
in the belief that I had played safe with my recommendations. There could
be no choke fatalities or broken teeth or bowel obstructions and as far as
I was aware there were no serious drawbacks. I recoil at the thought of how
misguided I then was. Because my patients did not complain and because I
practised in the conventional manner I was unaware that my patients' vast
array of ills and the diseases of old age were in fact mostly the result
of unnatural feeding.
Discussion with other members of the Raw Meaty Bone Lobby of concerned veterinarians
and our own researches enable me to say these things with confidence. Kittens
and puppies commenced early on a natural diet learn how to tackle their food
and in our experience seldom require veterinary attention. As if hit by a
thunder bolt we came to realise that many animals we had presumed to be suffering
from old age were in fact suffering an AIDS like syndrome. Happily we found
that the patients could be greatly improved and rushed the information to
a local veterinary journal. The findings were refused publication but now
vets and dog owners can find our results published in the December 1995 British
Journal of Small Animal Practice.
Our dietary induced AIDS patients have to date all shown speedy return to
good health. This we attribute to the dietary advice as provided in the JSAP:
'From day one after surgery the animals were fed a raw meaty bone diet with
occasional supplemental table scraps. The small dogs and cats received chicken
wings, rabbit legs and whole raw fish whilst the larger dogs received lamb
brisket, kangaroo tails, etc. The size of pieces was important as a regulator
of chewing function. Pieces too small would permit swallowing whole with
the risk of obstruction. Large bones without meat have lesser nutrient value
whilst risking the wear or breakage of teeth.'
As veterinarians and dog owners we have a duty to the few to ensure that
they do not choke in dramatic circumstances. Our duty to the many is that
they should not slide imperceptibly into protracted, debilitating dietary
induced AIDS.